
It took 120 minutes for Republic to win on Monday, securing themselves the Western Conference title and a shot at the USL Championship this coming Saturday. But, in many ways, the battle began Friday morning. With the nationwide ground stop in effect, Republic struggled to get to New Mexico at all. First, they tried flights out through the Sacramento airport throughout Friday and Saturday. When that didn’t work, they bussed the 2 hours down to the San Francisco airport Saturday evening, where a potential flight awaited. When that flight ended up canceled too, Republic had to take the bus back up to Sacramento and then charter 2 flights to New Mexico on Sunday, too late to make the planned Sunday night kickoff, forcing USL to push the match back to Monday.
Republic finally got to New Mexico around 7:30 Sunday night, after spending 3 days traveling with no ability to train, go through normal routines, or do their usual pre-match day activities. Obviously, this would be less than ideal under normal circumstances—but having it occur right before the Western Conference Final, against an opponent who was able to rest, train, and have their normal routine, did not make things easy.
So let’s get into why Republic won anyways.
The Lineup:
Now 16 matches undefeated, Collins felt no need to change things up from last week's win against El Paso. That’s not to say the tactics stayed the same, especially playing on a league minimum sized pitch, but Collins’ starting XI was identical to last week's. Even the time of the first subs was the same, roughly the 70th minute.
The largest difference in line up was how Collins managed those subs. While he utilized only 3 players off the bench against El Paso, he utilized 6 players against New Mexico, 5 of them in regulation time, and the coaching staff absolutely nailed the substitutions. Every single sub out performed the starter they replaced. The starting XI put up 2 shots on target, 7 total shots, and a 37.5% dual win rate. The subs? Four shots on target, 7 total shots, and 50% dual win rate. The substitutes (and Vitiello in goal) won Republic the game, not the starting XI. The starting 10 outfield players averaged a 6.73 player rating—decent, but average. The subs, however, averaged a 7.4 player rating, easily in the range of what I would consider “good.”
New Mexico also used an identical starting XI to their match last week against Colorado, but had the opposite problem from Republic. While their starting XI put up a 7.14 average player rating, their 5 substitutes put up just a 6.58 player rating.
The Tactics:
Tactically, this was a very open match. The match saw just 19 fouls over the 120 minutes, with just a single yellow card shown, and the flow of the game was fairly continuous, without much delay from restarts. This made for a very fun game to watch, but also made for a very different game than the start-stop nature that Republic faced when playing both Tulsa and El Paso, where both teams largely struggled to get into a good game flow.
The first major difference in tactics in this match was how comfortable Republic was with letting New Mexico have the ball, opting to press United in the middle 3rd of the pitch without forcing anything. New Mexico are a team that prefer to play short more than nearly any other team in USL—only 12.2% of their passes are classified as “long,” the 5th fewest in USL—so Republic pressed them and tried to force them to play over the top. Look how high each Republic line is here:

The center attacking midfield combo of Casas and Memo step up onto the ball to disrupt New Mexico as they try to build, but the 2nd line, in this case the CDM duo of MAK and Crisostomo, are right behind them in case New Mexico breaks out. In the back, Republic has a back 3 in a high line as well, though Desmond sits behind the center line as a sort of sweeper. It’s almost like Republic is baiting New Mexico to play over the top. Here, Republic win the ball and spring their first dangerous attack of the night, a shot by Jennings that hits the post and goes out.
Where Republic got themselves in trouble, at least in the first 90 minutes, was when they pushed the press or counter a little too early. Earlier in the year, Republic struggled against the counter when they sent both wingbacks, Benítez and Gurr, upfield at the same time. While this gives Republic a great offensive outlet on both sides of the pitch, it leaves just the 2 centerbacks at the back and is prone to issues with balls played out wide. In the wider confines of Heart Health Park in Sacramento, one of the wingbacks has stayed back at all times to create a back 3 with some width. However, in the more narrow confines of Isotope Park, Republic felt comfortable sending both forward.
To fix the issue of just having 2 centerbacks at the back in these cases, Republic relied on MAK and Crisistomos at CDM to slow the opposing offense down before it could counter—but issues arose when the CDM’s themselves were the ones to lose the ball. Look at this situation here:

MAK loses possession in the midfield, but after Gurr and Benítez (circled) have already triggered their forward press and so are wildly out of possession to deal with the New Mexico counter attack. The New Mexico midfielder has 2 options to just pass around Republic’s center backs. And no, the diagonal white line is not a figment of your imagination—that is the netting line for the baseball field. Why didn’t they take it down from right in front of the camera for this big of a game? Your guess is as good as mine.
Anyway, fortunately for Republic, Vitiello comes up with a massive save on this play, something that would be a common theme throughout the match. Of New Mexico’s 3 shots on target in the first half, all 3 came from similar situations—Republic’s wingbacks were upfield when New Mexico countered. Collins saw this discrepancy at half time and, coming out of the half, one of the wingbacks largely tucked into a back 3 when the other wingback went forward. Ironically, this led to New Mexico’s goal. Look at how inside left back Benítez is on this diagonal ball across the field:

He’s operating as a left centerback, pushing Desmond and Timmer out wide, because Gurr is up field. But this gives the United player, Dennis, plenty of space to receive the ball, beat Benítez on the dribble, and drop a dime of a cross into a space where Desmond and Timmer miss their marks because they’re trying to come back to the center of the field. Dennis was a menace (ha) all night on the right wing, winning 9 out of 13 duels. As United was forced by Sacramento’s press into playing the long ball more and more, they sought to create situations like this where they could isolate a single Republic player and then beat them on the dribble—strikingly similar to how Republic played against El Paso. New Mexico was 16 for 25 on dribble attempts compared to just 2 for 12 from Republic.
So how did Republic respond? With a pair of subs in the 70’, bringing in Midence for MAK, giving Republic a more creative wide player, and super sub Kyle Edwards for Cal Jennings, giving Republic a physical offensive force up top. Within a minute, Republic equalized off a Midence cross to Malango. But take a look at where Edwards is before the cross:

Edwards is actually occupying the attention of not one but 2 United defenders, and the 3rd defender is looking at him! Midence gets his cross in without much of a challenge due to isolating the defender guarding him, and Malango reads the cross perfectly, easily beating the defender marking him due to Edwards’ presence in the box. So within a minute, Collins' first 2 substitutes are the creators in Republic’s first goal.
The rest of the match sort of breaks down from a tactical perspective—both teams, afraid to risk too much before the end of regulation, hoof the ball up to their forwards to create chances. Just 3 more shots occur—one for United and 2 for Sacramento—before extra time, the best chance of the 3 occurring just a minute later when Edwards nearly chips the United keeper, who makes an incredible save.
Getting into extra time, I want to highlight something that Lee Desmond said after beating El Paso last week:
“the common theme is teams get tired against us, and that's down to the training we do. We've kind of noticed that the last six weeks stay in the game, and in the second half we seem to come really good, and teams seem to get tired.”
Despite Sacramento traveling for the last 3 days, fresh off any sort of training or normality, this appeared to be the case coming into extra time—New Mexico just seemed tired. Until the 120’, most of New Mexico’s attempts on goal were vague crosses into the box or off target shots that didn’t trouble Vitiello. But on the other side of the ball, Edwards punished a tired United backline, forcing them to track him again and again. The breakthrough finally came in the 102’, where a drop kick from Vitiello to Edwards was misread by the United defender, Edwards uses his strength to hold off the defender after the bounce, and then he 5-holes the keeper. The thing I want to highlight here is how casual the New Mexico backline is operating as this ball goes over the top:

Even after the first bounce, when Edwards gets into a better position on the United player, they’re still jogging back and no one even follows Midence streaking up field on the far side wide open. Even more wild for a Republic team that appears to be deadset on doing the remarkable, it is Vitiello’s first assist of his entire professional career and the first ever goalkeeper assist in USL Championship playoff history.
Republic bunkered down for the final 15 or so minutes of the match, bringing in Leibold for his first appearance in 6 weeks to provide defensive stability. But they needed more than just defense stability: Republic needed luck.
Yes, luck, the thing we have so often talked about here at Quail City Soccer due to the clubs propensity to say that have been unlucky. We talked about it as recently as August, where we tried to determine if Republic was unlucky or just not good enough. The final 10 minutes of the match required an incredible goal line clearance from Lee Desmond, before this sequence in the 122’ minute of the match:

New Mexico hit the crossbar, the ball falls for an open shot, and Freddy Kleemann blocks it, not looking, with his backside heel. It’s unbelievable. If Republic spent all season being “unlucky” just to get it on their side in the playoffs, I think they’ve found the trade off well worth it.
Match in Five:
-0.76xG
The amount Republic’s xG (1.75) trailed New Mexico’s xG (2.51)—by far the largest negative difference in a win that Republic pulled off this season.
88
The number of final 3rd entries for New Mexico, resulting in 17 shots
61
The number of final 3rd entries for Sacramento, resulting in 14 shots.
9
The number of “big chances” in the match total between the 2 teams— Republic scored just 2 of their 5, while United scored just 1 of their 4.
9 miles (14.5km)
Pep Casas total distance ran in the match, over a a half mile more than any other player on the pitch.
What’s Next:
I am going to be honest with you here—in every single metric outside of goals, Republic was the 2nd best team. xG, total shots, possession, shots on target, touches in the opposition's box, duels won, dribbles, you name it, Republic was behind New Mexico. But, for all the tactics we can pull out of those numbers, those numbers don’t win games: goals do. Intangible players win games. Players such as Kyle Edwards, who has 11 goals on the season but only 3 of those scored in games he’s started. Or Mayele Malango, who scored just his second goal of the season to equalize the match. Someone like Danny Vitiello who, despite playing 207 professional matches, just so happens to get his lone career assist on a game winning goal in extra time while putting up his second best goalkeeping performance of the season.
As most sports fans know, you need a special sort of magic to make a playoff run. You need the “it” factor, the intangible that the tactics just can’t break down, describe, or encapsulate. I don’t know if Republic will beat Lousiville on Saturday - the odds are fairly split, both teams are excellent, and it’s be a banger of a match—but I do know that just getting this far, especially after a season that mired in the middle with frustration and disappointment, Republic has the “it” factor this year. They have the magic.
And they’ll take that into a championship match on home turf on Saturday morning at 9 a.m. Grab a mimosa, grill up some breakfast, and we’ll see if Republic can use that magic one last time this season.



