
Photo Courtesy of Ryan Townsend
Sacramento has heard promises of Major League Soccer before. The city celebrated an expansion announcement in 2019, only to watch those plans collapse less than two years later when lead investor Ron Burkle withdrew. Since then, Sacramento Republic FC has continued building toward a future that could include MLS, but without any guarantee that the league would come calling again.
Now, Mayor Kevin McCarty has given Sacramento supporters another reason to pay attention, and the timing of his comments is difficult to ignore.
During his November 5 State of the City address, McCarty said Sacramento was "in the mix" for Major League Soccer and suggested an announcement could be coming soon, according to reporting by The Sacramento Bee. It was not the first time the mayor had hinted at something developing. In March, during Republic FC's announcement of its expanded 20,000-seat Railyards stadium, McCarty said an MLS opportunity was on the horizon.
At the time, Republic FC President and General Manager Tim Holt acknowledged that the ownership group was continuing to pursue MLS. The club, however, stopped short of suggesting an announcement was imminent.
Seven months later, McCarty's language has again raised expectations, this time against a considerably different backdrop.
On November 9, just four days after McCarty's latest comments, CF Montréal owner Joey Saputo announced that he was putting the Canadian MLS franchise up for sale. While Saputo expressed a preference for keeping the club in Montréal, he declined to make remaining in the city a condition of the sale. Any relocation would ultimately require MLS approval.
Montréal's availability creates another potential route into the league for markets like Sacramento, which have struggled to secure expansion opportunities. But it is not the only Canadian MLS franchise facing an uncertain future.
The Vancouver Whitecaps have been on the market since December 2024, and their situation took a significant turn earlier this year. In April, The Athletic reported that a special committee of MLS owners had met to evaluate Vancouver's future, including potential relocation. Las Vegas emerged as the principal destination discussed, with Phoenix another leading candidate.
MLS Commissioner Don Garber subsequently acknowledged the possibility of moving the Whitecaps if the club could not resolve its stadium challenges at BC Place. The league's concerns centered on the club's limited control over scheduling, commercial revenue and premium seating.
The significance for Sacramento is not that either Canadian franchise has been connected to a confirmed local bid. Neither has. Rather, MLS has demonstrated that relocating an existing franchise is an option it is willing to consider, while Sacramento has continued preparing for an opportunity to join the league.
That brings the conversation back to March.
When Republic FC announced that its new Railyards stadium would open with more than 20,000 seats instead of the previously planned 12,000-seat first phase, the club committed to a facility capable of accommodating the ambitions it had pursued for years. The larger stadium had already been contemplated in earlier planning, but the decision to build it at full capacity from the beginning represented a substantial commitment.
McCarty's statement that an MLS opportunity was on the horizon came alongside that announcement, weeks before reports emerged about MLS owners formally discussing Vancouver's possible relocation.
That sequence does not establish a connection between the stadium decision and Vancouver. It does, however, show that Sacramento's elected leadership and Republic FC's ownership were publicly discussing MLS opportunities while the league was confronting questions about the future of an existing franchise.
The November comments introduce a similar coincidence. McCarty suggested an announcement could be approaching just days before Montréal became the second Canadian MLS club publicly available for purchase.
There is an important distinction, however. Unlike Vancouver, where MLS owners have reportedly evaluated relocation, there is no publicly confirmed relocation process involving Montréal. Forbes reported on November 10, citing a source close to the league, that Saputo and MLS had not discussed relocating the club. A prospective buyer seeking to move Montréal would also face a substantial relocation fee.
There is also no public evidence that Republic FC's ownership, Wilton Rancheria or another Sacramento investment group has submitted an offer for either Canadian franchise.
Still, the repeated comments from McCarty deserve clarification. In March, the mayor spoke of an opportunity on the horizon. In November, he suggested an announcement could be coming. Those are two different moments, separated by seven months, during which the circumstances surrounding MLS expansion and relocation have continued to evolve.
The question is whether McCarty is speaking from knowledge of specific developments or expressing confidence in Sacramento's long-standing pursuit of the league.
It is reasonable that the mayor would be informed about major economic development opportunities involving the Railyards, particularly given the city's involvement in the stadium project. But there is a considerable difference between being aware of exploratory conversations and knowing that an agreement is approaching.
Quail City Soccer has contacted both Mayor McCarty's office and Sacramento Republic FC seeking clarification regarding the November 5 remarks, including whether the mayor was referring to active discussions involving MLS expansion, a potential franchise relocation or the club's broader ambitions. Neither had responded at the time of publication.
There are other questions that remain unanswered. Would Republic FC's current ownership group pursue an existing MLS franchise rather than wait for another expansion opportunity? Would such a transaction require additional investors beyond those already involved in the Railyards development? And if McCarty believes an announcement is approaching, what specifically has changed since March?
For Sacramento supporters, the possibility of MLS returning to the conversation is familiar territory. The city has already experienced the excitement of an expansion announcement and the disappointment of watching it unravel. That history makes it particularly important to distinguish between genuine progress and another round of speculation.
The circumstances today are different from those of 2019. Sacramento has an advancing stadium project, a committed majority ownership group and a league that has publicly acknowledged relocation as a possibility for at least one existing franchise.
But the missing piece remains the same: confirmation of an agreement.
McCarty may simply be expressing optimism about a future he believes Sacramento is moving toward. Or his comments may reflect discussions that have not yet become public. At present, the available evidence cannot establish which explanation is correct.
What makes this worth investigating is not the coincidence of two Canadian clubs being available for sale. It is that Sacramento's mayor has twice publicly pointed toward an MLS opportunity, and his latest suggestion of an approaching announcement came at a time when the league's franchise landscape was already changing.
For now, Sacramento is left with a familiar question, but one that deserves a more specific answer than it has received so far. When the mayor says MLS news could be coming soon, what exactly does he know?


